Your go-to guide for finding the right Amelia Island vacation rental, from neighborhoods and amenities to stay styles and standout homes.
If you’re planning a coastal getaway in Northeast Florida, Amelia Island and Fernandina Beach offer a very different experience from Florida’s larger resort corridors. The appeal here lies in space, walkable neighborhoods, historic character, and beaches that still feel open even during peak season.
But here’s what makes a trip to this Florida gem especially memorable: staying in one of the island’s incredible vacation rentals. Believe me, where you stay plays a big role in shaping the experience. On Amelia Island, you’ll be spoiled for choice, with many types of vacation rentals scattered across different parts of the island. Knowing how to choose the right one for your style of vacation is essential for a truly five-star stay.
At Stay Better Vacations, we offer a handpicked collection of vacation rentals across Amelia Island and the charming town of St. Marys, Georgia. From relaxed beachfront stays to homes close to history and local flavor, plus plenty of pet-friendly options, it’s easy to find a place that fits the way you want to travel. Planning an Amelia Island escape and looking for tips? Visit our travel blog, where our local experts share curated guides on vacationing with dogs, biking around Amelia Island, top annual events, and more.
TL;DR: Choosing the Right Vacation Rental on Amelia Island and Fernandina Beach
- Why vacation rentals make sense on Amelia Island
- Understanding Amelia Island’s main areas and neighborhoods
- Types of vacation rentals available across the island
- Top amenities to look for in an Amelia Island rental
- How to choose the right rental for your trip
- Top-rated vacation rentals on Amelia Island
1. Why Vacation Rentals Make Sense on Amelia Island
Amelia Island stretches for more than 13 miles, and each area has its own feel. Staying in a vacation rental lets you choose your location first, then enjoy the comfort, privacy, and flexibility that come with it.
Here are some key advantages of vacation rentals on the island:
- More space indoors and out, especially for families and groups.
- Well-equipped kitchens and dining areas that fit longer stays.
- Residential settings close to beaches, trails, and historic streets.
- Pet-friendly options that are common and well-regulated.
2. Understanding Amelia Island’s Main Areas
Before choosing a rental, it helps to understand how the island is laid out.
Fernandina Beach Historic District
This lovely area is ideal for travelers who enjoy walkability, architecture, restaurants, and shops. Rentals here often include historic homes, apartments, and cottages close to Centre Street.
Best for:
- Couples.
- Culture-focused travelers.
- Holiday stays and short getaways.
Central Amelia Island
Mid-island neighborhoods balance beach access with residential calm. You’ll find townhomes, condos, and single-family homes within short drives or bike rides to both the ocean and downtown.
Best for:
- Families.
- Longer stays.
- Travelers wanting flexibility.
South End of Amelia Island
Closer to resort developments and golf courses, this area features many condos and larger homes with beach access, pools, and resort-style amenities.
Best for:
- Golfers.
- Multi-generational groups.
- Travelers prioritizing amenities.
3. Types of Vacation Rentals on Amelia Island
Beach Houses
Standalone homes near the beach offer the most privacy and flexibility. Many include outdoor living areas, multiple bedrooms, and parking, which matters more here than in denser destinations.
Common features:
- Private yards, decks, and pools.
- Multiple bathrooms.
- Space for bikes, beach gear, and pets.
- Short walks or drives to beach access.
Townhomes
Townhomes provide a middle ground between condos and houses. These multi-level properties often sit in quieter neighborhoods while still offering shared amenities.
Common features:
- Large balconies or patios.
- Community pools or beach access.
- Residential surroundings.
Condos
Condos are popular along the southern end of the island and near beachfront access points. They often provide convenience and shared amenities without the maintenance of a larger property. They are also a good fit for more budget-conscious visitors.
Common features:
- Oceanfront or ocean-view options.
- Parking.
- Pools and fitness rooms.
- On-site beach access.
4. Top Amenities to Look for in an Amelia Island Rental
The right amenities can make or break a stay. Choosing a property with the right essentials and extras for the type of vacation you imagine is key to turning it into something exceptional rather than ordinary. The focus should be on what supports daily comfort for you and your vacation crew, along with outdoor living.
Here are some of the top amenities you should look for when searching for the ideal vacation rental on Amelia Island:
– Beach Gear: Chairs, umbrellas, carts, towels, and sometimes bikes — small extras that save time and money.
– Outdoor Space: Balconies, porches, and patios extend living space year-round, especially during spring and fall. Private pools and grills are also essential if you’re looking for something that will give you a true sense of being on vacation and convenient entertainment without having to leave your place.
– Pet-Friendly Features: If traveling with your furry companion, look for fenced yards, nearby walking routes, and clear house rules.
– Well-equipped kitchen: Full-size appliances, decent cookware, and enough space to cook without frustration.
– Comfortable living areas: Plenty of seating, good lighting, and space for everyone to spread out.
– Proximity to what you’ll use most: Walkable beach access, quick drives to Centre Street, or quiet residential settings.
5. How to Choose the Right Rental for Your Trip
Match the Rental to Your Daily Plans
If you plan to walk to dinner every night, stay near downtown. If beach time dominates your days, prioritize access over views.
Consider Seasonality
Spring and fall favor outdoor spaces. Summer highlights shade and proximity to water. Winter stays benefit from sun-facing balconies and walkable locations.
Think About Group Dynamics
Multi-generational groups often appreciate separate sleeping areas and multiple bathrooms. Couples may prioritize location and ambiance instead.
Read Location Descriptions Carefully
“Near the beach” can mean different things. Check walking distances and access points.
Book Early for Peak Periods
Spring break, summer, holidays, and events like the Amelia Island Concours draw high demand.
6. Top-Rated Vacation Rentals on Amelia Island
This second-floor oceanfront condo on South Fletcher sits right above the shoreline, with open Atlantic views and sunrise right outside your window. The gated setting feels private, and features like a pool, private pier, and courts give you plenty to do without going far.
Highlights
- Oceanfront balcony with direct sunrise views.
- Gated complex with private pier.
- Oceanside pool and tennis courts.
- Three-bedroom layout with updated finishes.
This adults-only condo pairs a calm, coastal interior with direct beach access and an oceanside pool. The nearby Surf Restaurant offers an effortless option for nights out without having to drive. The cherry on the cake is the fourth-floor views, stretching wide over the Atlantic from a private, stylish balcony.
Highlights
- Fourth-floor oceanfront balcony boasting stylish decor.
- Primary bedroom with ocean views and an ensuite.
- Oceanside pool within the complex.
- Two designated parking spaces.
Set within the Beach Walker community at Amelia Island Plantation, this multi-level villa layers ocean views, coastal design, and access to trails, beaches, and island amenities. Each level offers its own retreat, culminating in a top-floor primary suite facing the Atlantic.
Highlights
- Oceanfront multi-level villa.
- Three king bedrooms with en-suites and shared baths.
- Beach Walker oceanside pool and grilling area.
- Gated community with 24-hour security.
- Dog-friendly for small dogs.
Tucked into Old Town Fernandina Beach, this restored 1920s cottage balances historic character with modern comfort. Screened porches, a firepit patio, and generous light-filled interiors create a home base suited to longer stays. Beaches, downtown streets, and waterfront paths sit only minutes away.
Highlights
- Restored historic cottage.
- Three bedrooms and three full baths.
- Multiple porches and outdoor spaces.
- Firepit and outdoor shower.
- Well-equipped kitchen with modern appliances.
- Parking for two vehicles.
Built in 1889, this three-story Victorian will steal the hearts of those who love architecture. Heart pine floors, stained glass, clawfoot tubs, and generous porches shape a stay rooted in Fernandina’s past. The brick courtyard and citrus trees add extra charm and allure.
Highlights
- Four bedrooms across three levels.
- Original Victorian architectural details.
- Screened porch and brick courtyard.
- Dedicated workspace for remote stays.
- Pickleball gear with court access.
Just steps from 4N Beach Access, this two-bedroom home is all about location and outdoor living. Two balconies, a covered hangout space, and a fenced yard allow guests to relax after days at the beach or exploring town. Spots like Main Beach, Fort Clinch, and downtown Fernandina are nearby, making getting around especially convenient.
Highlights
- Beach access less than 150 yards away.
- Two balconies with partial ocean views.
- Covered outdoor hangout with TV and ping pong.
- Fully fenced yard.
- Outdoor shower and gas grill.
Make Your Trip to Amelia Island Even Better
Specializing in boutique-style service, Stay Better Vacations offers thoughtfully curated vacation rentals across Amelia Island, Florida, and St. Marys, Georgia. As a locally owned, women-operated company, we focus on warm Southern hospitality and stays that feel personal, relaxed, and easy. Get ready for beach days, coastal adventures, and time well spent with family or friends. Traveling with a pup? Select pet-friendly vacation rentals make it simple to include every member of the crew.
